ATLAS:DIY
EMPOWERING IMMIGRANT YOUTH AND THEIR ALLIES
UNLOCKING IMMIGRANT YOUTH'S ACCESS TO LEGAL SERVICES, LEADERSHIP DEVELOPMENT AND LEARNING OPPORTUNITIES IN A SPACE OWNED RUN AND GOVERNED BY THE YOUTH.
About Programs In the News Donate Community Resources Subscribe Contact

ATLAS:DIY BLOG

February 7, 2013
How Arizona is alienating 9% of its population - and wasting YOUR money to do it
Atlas DIY is an immigration empowerment center that works to promote immigrant rights, and comprehensive immigration reform, not Jan Brewer.

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer has been at the front of anti-immigrant and anti-Latino movements across the United States. Her government has written and passed a variety of restrictive and discriminatory laws, including those targetting Deferred Action recipients.

Over the past year or so, we have witnessed a slew of discriminatory laws coming from Arizona. Ranging from forcing local police to act as immigration enforcement to denying deferred action recipients the benefits given to them through federal actions, these bills all have three things in common: They are inherently discriminatory, they make life harder for those living in Arizona, and they waste precious government resources at a time when are economy is already hurting.

Legislature introduced and backed by Arizona State Rep. Steve Smith (R) continues this trend of bad policy-making. Arizona’s “English Only” law is a piece of legislature that would prohibit mailing government documents in languages other than English — a mandate that critics say would violate the Civil Rights Act which states government cannot discriminate against its non-English speaking population. There are currently nearly 600,000 people living in Arizona who speak only limited English.

But aside from going contrary to current civil rights laws, this proposed legislature (and others like it that have emerged in Arizona in the past) fails Arizonans in several ways.

Waste of Resources

Proponents of the bill say that it will cut government spending because it removed the printing of government documents in any language but English  This is utterly ridiculous. What they fail to explain is that the bill would not cut down on the printing or mailing of government resources, it would merely stop the production of documents in Spanish and replace them with documents in English.

So now people who previously received mail from the government in a language they understood, would in the future be receiving these documents in English – a transition that would spell trouble for the full 9% of Arizona’s population that speaks limited English  That increases the waist factor on these documents by 9% – something we cannot afford in this economy.

English-Only bill is inherently discriminatory

In addition to adding to government waist, this proposed legislation would also discriminate against the people of Arizona. If the legislation does not improve efficiency or have significant societal benefits, why propose it? It is merely a slap in the face of Latinos that lawmakers claim to be courting. It makes life harder for Spanish-speaking citizens living in Arizona, who already have to deal with a slew of anti-immigrant and anti-Latino measures that have been passed in the past few years.

Finally, lets make the analogy of Arizona to a business. Do you know what happens to a business that makes life hard for its customers? Its customers move on. Arizona lawmakers should take that into consideration before alienating a tenth of their population.

If you like this article, please feel take a moment to like, stare, and tweet it to your followers. It really helps!

SEARCH BY KEYWORD

GO

ARCHIVES BY MONTH

Archives By Month

FOLLOW US

Atlas DIY

462 36th Street, #PH-B,
Brooklyn, NY 11232
347-599-1641
info@atlasdiy.org
©AtlasDIY 2016
We are not your legal representative nor can we be held liable for any actions you take.
Login to MyAtlas via or
and earn rewards for sharing!
Share this page
+50 pts each
Share (+50 pts) or Like (+25 pts) this pageShare
this page
Share this page Or log in and earn points!
 00  4  Like on FB
+25 pts
 Close